MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
13 August 2009
MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
2Q09
OVERVIEW
2Q09 result was a seasonally weak quarter, added with the macro weakness from
the political turmoil during Songkran (Thai New Year in April) and the
outbreak of H1N1 influenza. These factors prompt the company to review the
guidance for FY2009 as 1H09 came below expectation and the outlook for 2H09
appear less optimistic due to the prolonged impact from H1N1 and the pressure
to consumer sentiment on renewed hike in oil price as well as political
uncertainty, subsequently could delay economic recovery in 2H09.
AIS expects FCF growth of 15% y-o-y, although the revenue outlook is revised
down to -3% to 0% to reflect the weaker-than-expected 1H09 and slow recovery
in 2H09 from both domestic usage and international roaming (-30% yoy). One of
the key drivers for the growth is our success in cost control measures shown
in the improved service EBITDA margin* from 44.6% to 45.2% albeit the lower
revenues during 1H09. In respect to weaker demand and revenue forecast, capex
is also revised down to Bt11bn, 6bn of which spent in 1H09. For the 1H09, AIS
generated Bt16.7bn of free cash flow or 6% increase from 1H08.
Data growth continued to be strong driven by internet SIM resulted in 39%
y-o-y growth of revenue from mobile internet during 1H09. Sales of USB modem
for data usage has been rising rapidly during the quarters, attributable to the
mobility usage penetrated more into laptop users and partly the availability
of inexpensive netbook. This suggests the strong demand for wireless internet
access remained despite the weak economy.
Competition continued to focus on retaining usage of existing subscribers
rather than new acquisition as reflected in lower industry net additions. To
help sustain usage, AIS introduced a new buffet plan with lower monthly fee
from Bt199 (Buffet Day) to Bt49 (Ngan Khao - Get Job) in the event of economic
difficulties Sawasdee, the brand for low usage customers, are used to
penetrate further into low-utilisation areas including extended validity for
small refill to encourage ongoing usage. Postpaid acquisition also came with
reasonable quality and ARPU from the success of "Mixed & Match" package due to
its simplicity while its tariffs are similar to prepaid level and more
comparable to competitor's offering in the market. The promotion is hence
attractive to both new and existing subscribers as well as those who wants to
move from prepaid to postpaid.
*service EBITDA margin (excluding handset business) is calculated based
on separated financial statement of 1H09 and 1H08
OPERATIONAL HIGHLIGHTS
Subscriber reached 27.9m, with growth mainly from upcountry market
ARPU and Usage fell due to the impact of seasonality softness and weak IR
revenue
Subscriber recorded 27.9m,improved 1.2% q-o-q, and 7.5% y-o-y representing
320k net additions compared to 272k in 1Q09 and 877k in 2Q08.
The subscriber growth was mostly from rural market particulary
the North and the Northeast region.
ARPU & MOU declined from seasonal softness in usage and weak international
roaming revenue. Postpaid ARPU including net IC fell 4.6% q-o-q
to Bt605, while MOU was more stable with a 0.8% qoq drop,
sustained by usage from Mix & Match package. Prepaid ARPU
including net IC contracted 3.4% q-o-q to Bt196, while its MOU
declined 1.6% q-o-q.
FINANCIAL RESULTS
Service revenue excluded IC fell 5.4% y-o-y from weak usage especially IR
revenue .
EBITDA declined 6.3% y-o-y from lower revenue
Net profit of Bt4,197m in 2Q09 fell 18% y-o-y from higher amortization
Service revenue 2Q08 1Q09 2Q09 y-o-y q-o-q
excluding IC
(Bt million)
Voice revenue 16,287 77.3% 15,422 75.1% 15,244 76.5% -6.4% -1.2%
Postpaid (voice) 3,844 18.3% 3,674 17.9% 3,650 18.3% -5.0% -0.7%
Prepaid (voice) 12,443 59.1% 11,747 57.2% 11,593 58.2% -6.8% -1.3%
Non-voice revenue 2,666 12.7% 3,168 15.4% 3,151 15.8% 18.2% -0.5%
International roaming 952 4.5% 832 4.0% 547 2.7% -42.5% -34.2%
Others
(IDD, other fees) 1,155 5.5% 1,125 5.5% 990 5.0% -14.3% -12.0%
Total service revenue
excl. IC 21,060 100.0% 20,546 100.0% 19,932 100.0% -5.4% -3.0%
Service revenue exclude IC revenue in 2Q09 declined 3% q-o-q mostly from the
drastic decline in international roaming due to the flu pandemic since
beginning of May. Domestic voice usage was also weak from the seasonal
effect and the exceptional lengthy Songkran holiday in April. On y-o-y basis,
service revenue declined 5.4% on weak usage following economic slowdown as
well as the Songkran incident and the flu impact.
Voice revenue Voice revenue declined 1.2% q-o-q on seasonal weakness of usage
on both prepaid and postpaid.
For the 1H09, voice revenue declined 6% y-o-y due to overall economic weakness.
Other revenue declined 12% q-o-q and 14% y-o-y from the weakness in
international call (IDD) revenue which was also impacted by lower foreign
tourists.
Net interconnection (IC) was higher q-o-q with net receipt of Bt319m compared
to Bt273m in 1Q09. While incoming traffic continued to decrease (-2.7%), the
higher net IC was driven by the stronger decline in outgoing traffic (-4.2%).
On-net traffic continued to rise to 78% from 77% in previous quarter.
Sales revenues fell 19% q-o-q and 48% y-o-y as consumer demand for handset
shrank following economic slowdown. In addition, the change in Nokia's
distribution policy also limited company's sales starting in February only to
Bangkok area. Sales margin was 2.7% compared to 2.2% in 1Q09 and 8.8% in
2Q08. The pressure to sales margin was from a conservative policy to manage
handset inventory aging by actively destocking as demand outlook remains weak.
Interconnection (Bt million) 2Q08 1Q09 2Q09 y-o-y q-o-q
Revenue 4,144 3,721 3,621 -12.6% -2.7%
Cost 4,080 3,447 3,302 -19.1% -4.2%
Net Interconnection 64 273 319 396% 16.8%
Cost of service excl.IC (Bt million)
Amortization 4,426 4,596 4,733 6.9% 3.0%
Base station rental & utility 628 651 679 8.1% 4.3%
Maintenance 427 428 350 -18.0% -18.1%
Others 929 944 957 2.9% 1.4%
Cost of service excl. IC 6,411 6,618 6,719 4.8% 1.5%
SG&A (Bt million)
Marketing expense 572 519 658 15.0% 26.8%
Administrative expense 2,002 1,896 1,729 -13.6% -8.8%
SG&A expenses 2,574 2,415 2,387 -7.3% -1.2%
%marketing to total revenue 2.0% 2.0% 2.6%
%bad debt to postpaid revenue 2.2% 3.6% 3.9%
%SG&A to total revenue 9.1% 9.2% 9.5%
EBITDA (Bt million) 2Q08 1Q09 2Q09 y-o-y q-o-q
Operating profit 7,365 6,849 6,342 -13.9% -7.4%
Depreciation PPE 752 765 836
Network amortization 3,915 4,075 4,146
Gain (loss) on disposals of PPE 57 -1 0
Management benefit -26 -17 -16
Other financial cost -16 -20 -18
EBITDA 12,048 11,652 11,289 -6.3% -3.1%
EBITDA margin 42.5% 44.3% 44.8%
Financial Cost 2Q08 1Q09 2Q09 y-o-y q-o-q
Interest expenses 394 488 478 21.3% -2.0%
Other financial costs 16 20 18 17.6% -6.1%
Financial cost 410 508 497 21.2% -2.1%
Consolidated 2Q08 1Q09 2Q09 y-o-y q-o-q
(Bt million)
Net income 6,333 4,567 4,197 -33.7% -8.1%
Deduct: Gain on DPC settlement
after tax (1,217)
Normalized net income 5,116 4,567 4,197 -18.0% -8.1%
Non-voice revenue was relatively flat q-o-q as SMS fell from the New Year
season in 1Q but offset by growth on mobile internet and content download. The
y-o-y growth remained strong at 18% for 1H09 due to higher subscription to
data plan using AIS data USB modem, attributable to the growth of mobile
internet access among laptop users International roaming revenue (IR) fell 34%
q-o-q compared to the usual q-o-q drop in 2Q of 16-18% as a result of lower
tourist arrival affected by political insurgence in April as well as fear of
H1N1 flu. For 1H09, IR revenue declined 34% y-o-y.
Cost of service exclude IC cost rose 1.5% q-o-q and 4.8% y-o-y from higher
amortization due to shorten period of BTO contract, this was partly offset by
lower network maintenance which fell 18% both q-o-q and y-o-y as part of the
effort to control operating expense. Cost of base station rental and utility
rose 4.3% q-o-q and 8.1% y-o-y as number of base station rose to 15,165 from
14,900 in 1Q09 and 13,600 in 2Q08. For 1H09, cost of service excl. IC rose
4.4% from 6% higher amortization while operating saving was achieved on
network maintenance and lower cost of refill cards due to the growth of refill
on mobile.
Revenue sharing expense declined 2.7% q-o-q and 4.0% y-o-y following the
decrease in service revenue. In addition, DPC a subsidiary that operates
1800MHz has informed TOT and CAT of the concellation of access charge
agreement and ceased the access charge payment (Bt200/sub/month) to TOT from
1 June 2009 onward to comply with interconnection regulation from NTC. The
amount was approximately Bt48m per quarter.
Marketing spending rose 27% q-o-q and 15% y-o-y due to several ongoing
marketing campaigns to maintain the strong brand presence in upcountry
markets in particular the "Sawasdee Luk Tung Tour Thai" concerts as well as
Songkran event. For 1H09, however, marketing expense declined 3.1% y-o-y while
its % to total revenue remained well under control at 2.3% below the budget of
3%.
Administrative expense decreased 8.8% q-o-q and 13.6% y-o-y as a result of
lower staff cost and reversed provision of handset inventory that was cleared
during the quarter. Bad debt provision was slightly higher to 3.9% of postpaid
revenue compared to 3.6% in 1Q09 and 2.2% in 2Q08 due to the postpaid growth
into lower segment. For 1H09, administrative expense declined 6.9% y-o-y from
lower staff cost and reversed provision.
Other income was Bt138m, declined 25% q-o-q from lower interest income as
cash position reduced. On y-o-y basis, other income fell from Bt1,944m in 2Q08
which included the one-time gain from DPC settlement.
EBITDA was Bt11,289m, declined 3.1% q-o-q and 6.3% y-o-y following the
decrease in revenue, partly offset by higher net IC receipt, lower maintenance
and administrative expenses. EBITDA margin in 2Q09 was 44.8% slightly increased
from 44.3% in 1Q09 and 42.5% in 2Q08 due to the declined in handset sales
proportion which contributes minimal margin. For 1H09, EBITDA was Bt22,941m,
declined 5.7% from previous year due to the decline of service revenue
especially prepaid revenue and international roaming revenue but partly offset
by improvement in net IC receipt, lower staff & administrative cost, as well
as decline in cost of refill cards. EBITDA margin for 1H09 was 44.5%, up from
42.7% in 1H08 as the handset proportion fell.
Financial cost declined 2.1% q-o-q but increased 21% y-o-y from higher
outstanding debt of Bt39bn in 2Q09 compared to Bt30bn as of 2Q08.
Net profit for 2Q09 was Bt4,197m, fell 8.1% q-o-q from higher amortization
and interest expense. On y-o-y basis net profit declined 33.7% due to one-time
gain on DPC settlement. Excluding the gain, recurring net profit declined
18.3% y-o-y due to higher amortization and interest expense. For 1H09,
recurring net profit was Bt8,764m, declined 14.4% y-o-y.
Balance sheet structure
Bt million 1Q09 %to total 2Q09 %to total
asset asset
Cash 30,053 21.8% 27,368 20.8%
ST investment 20 0.0% 34 0.0%
Trade receivable 5,094 3.7% 5,479 4.2%
Inventory 1,266 0.9% 907 0.7%
Other 2,536 1.8% 2,374 1.8%
Current Asset 38,968 28.3% 36,162 27.5%
Networks and PPE 79,318 57.6% 76,899 58.4%
Intangible asset 6,529 4.7% 6,437 4.9%
Defer tax asset 10,075 7.3% 9,940 7.5%
Others 2,753 2.0% 2,260 1.7%
Total Assets 137,644 100.0% 131,698 100.0%
Trade accounts payable 3,826 2.8% 3,990 3.0%
CP of LT loans 3,889 2.8% 3,923 3.0%
Accrued R/S expense 4,058 2.9% 5,166 3.9%
Others 10,781 7.8% 9,371 7.1%
Current Liabilities 22,553 16.4% 22,450 17.0%
Total interest-bearing debt 39,084 28.4% 39,317 29.9%
Total Liabilities 59,596 43.3% 59,203 45.0%
Total Equity 78,048 56.7% 72,495 55.0%
Total asset fell 4.3% q-o-q to Bt131,698m from Bt137,664m in 1Q09, caused by
lower cash which declined to Bt27,368m in 2Q09 from Bt30,053m in 1Q09 mainly
due to the dividend payment of Bt9,774m in May. Additionally, network,
property and equipment declined 3.1% q-o-q as the amortization of assets was
greater than new capex.
Liquidity The considerable cash built up from issued debentures of Bt7.5bn
during 1Q09 enhanced the company to maintain high level of liquidity with
current ratio of 1.61 in 2Q09, dropped from 1.73 in 1Q09. Inventory also
declined significantly from previous quarter due to active destocking of
handsets, while current liabilities was relatively flat.
Debentures and loans in 2Q09 slightly increased to Bt39,317m from Bt39,084m in
1Q09. Average cost of debt in 2Q09 was 4.7% compared to 4.8% in 1Q09 and 5.3%
in 2Q08 with all foreign debt fully hedged.
Bt million 1Q09 2Q09
Debt ratio 43% 45%
Net debt to equity 12% 16%
Total liabilities to equity 76% 82%
Capital structure With the lower equity from dividend payment during the
period, total liability to equity rose to 82% from 76% in 1Q09. The capital
structure nevertheless remained strong with Net debt to equity of 16%.
End of Repayment
Unit: million 2Q09 2H09 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Long term loan(1) 16,420 247 494 9,979 494 494 2,939
Debenture(2) 22,897 3,427 - 4,000 5,000 8,000 2,500
Total debt 39,317 3,674 494 13,979 5,494 8,494 5,439
(1) includes swap contract; (2) includes bond issuing cost
Cash Flow
Cash flow position remained strong to supported both CAPEX and debt repayment.
For 1H09, the Company generated operating cash flow before change in working
capital of Bt23.6bn while spent Bt5.9bn in capex, repaid Bt3.5bn of debt, and
paid Bt9.8bn in dividend.
Source and use of fund: 1H09 1H09
million
Source of Fund Use of Fund
Operating CF before change CAPEX & Fixed assets 5,951
in working capital 23,620
Proceed from LT borrowing 8,535 Dividend payment 9,774
Interest received 157 Finance cost paid 1,010
Investment 90 Cash increase 11,273
Disposal of property and equipment 11 Repayment of LT borrowing 3,516
Share capital and share premium 69 Changes in working capital 959
Total 32,483 Total 32,483
FY2009 MANAGEMENT OUTLOOK & STRATEGY(REVISED)
Market subscriber forecast 5m net additions for the market
Market share Maintain revenue market share
Free cash flow** +15% y-o-y
Service revenue** -3% to 0% service revenue growth
**revised from 3-4%
Marketing expense 3% of total revenue (equivalent to 3.5%
of total revenue excluding IC)
Network amortization** 7-8% rise (network amortization and
depreciation as booked under cost of service
only, exclude PPE depreciation in SGA, and
amortization of operation right)
**revised from 8-10%
EBITDA margin 41-42%
Capex** Bt11bn cash capex (including 3G on 900MHz)
**revised from 13-15bn
Net IC revenue Bt400-700m
FY09 guidance is revised to reflect worse-than-expected 2Q09 and company's
outlook of slower economic recovery during the 2H09. 2Q09 result was
negatively impacted by unexpected events from the political turmoil during
Songkran (Thai New Year in April) and H1N1 influenza. For 2H09, major
challenges are on the demand side that remains weak, renewed climb in oil
price, political uncertainty, and the prolonged impact of H1N1 influenza.
Service revenue growth (excluding interconnection revenue) is hence revised
down to -3% to 0% from previously 3-4%. Voice usage, the largest contributor
to revenue, is expected to remain weak with slower recovery in 2H09 while
stable competition continued.
International roaming and to the lesser degree international call were
significantly impacted by the decrease in tourist arrivals following the H1N1
influenza. International roaming revenue is now expected to decline 30% y-o-y.
Data revenue however remained healthy and was in-line with our expectation;
its growth target hence is maintained at 10-15%.
Despite the lower revenue growth forecast, company expects to grow free cash
flow by 15% y-o-y with cost efficiency program being implemented on both
operating expense and capital expenditure. Consolidated EBITDA margin is
expected at 41-42% albeit the lower revenue forecast due to (1) the forecasted
lower proportion of revenue from handset business which usually erode
consolidated margin, (2) lower gross interconnection revenue while net
interconnection receipt is expected to be similar to FY08, and (3) operational
cost saving on network maintenance, lower cost of refill cards as company is
pushing on refill-on-mobile, as well as lower staff cost and administrative
expenses. With slower demand forecast and continued stable outlook on
competition, capex is revised down to Bt11bn from the previous Bt13-15bn. The
cost management on both opex and capex is targeted to enhance the
company's ability to deliver strong free cash flow and hence consistent return
to shareholders with an expected growth on FCF of 15% y-o-y.
Handset sales is expected to decline significantly from weak consumer spending
as well as the change in Nokia's distribution policy starting from February
which limited sales for company's distribution arm to only Bangkok area.
Handset business this year is expected to contribute near-zero gross margin in
a short run. In addition, we have been maintaining a conservative inventory
provisioning policy. Despite the short-term negative impact and potential
smaller scale of business, it remains as a vital part to support overall
strategy for AIS on growing mobile service and to support the future launch of
3G service.
The mobile penetration in 2H09 is expected to grow over 100% with organic
demand continues from upcountry market that contributes lower ARPU. AIS's
strength in rural network coverage, premium quality and distinctive brand
presence will be the key to win in these markets and will serve the aim to
maintain overall revenue market share. During the economy slowdown,
competition outlook remains benign while mobile operators shift the focus to
retaining usage from existing subscriber as well as quality customer and
loyalty program rather than aggressive acquisition which would drive
further multiple SIMs.
3G license will be the key milestone this year as AIS is working closely on
all fronts to ensure highest possibility of attaining the new license which
will allow all industry players to operate at more level-playing field under a
fair cost structure. AIS expects NTC to auction 2.1GHz spectrum in 1Q10.
Operationally, AIS has been preparing for readiness to ensure the shortest
launch time for commercial service. Financially, AIS is also well-shaped to
support the funding needs, partly reflected in the success of debenture
issuance in Jan-09. While macro environment post a significant challenge this
year, the operational large-scale advantage and solid financial strength will
support AIS's flexibility to grow amidst this tough year.
Disclaimer
"Some statements made in this presentation are forward-looking statements,
which are subject to various risks and uncertainties. These include
statements with respect to our corporate plans, strategies and beliefs and
other statements that are not historical facts. These statements can be
identified by the use of forward-looking terminology such as "may" , "will" ,
"expect" , "anticipate", "intend" , "estimate" , "continue" "plan" or other
(more)