Management Discussion & Analysis 3Q08
11 พฤศจิกายน 2551
3Q08 MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION & ANALYSIS
OPERATIONAL HIGHLIGHTS
*Subscribers reached 26.8m with continued penetration in upcountry
*ARPU and MOU declined q-o-q on seasonality impact
Subscribers as of 3Q08 grew 15.4% y-o-y and 3.1% q-o-q to 26.8m with net
additions of 810k. The growth was driven by upcountry penetration. For 9M08,
AIS added in total 2.7m subscribers.
Prepaid was impacted by seasonality and the flood, which reflected in lower
net additions during the quarter, as well as slow down usage and ARPU. Net
additions were 661k for the quarter, lower from 862k in the previous quarter.
The majority of net add was from higher penetration in upcountry area. ARPU
excl. IC fell 7.2% y-o-y due to dilution from multiple-SIM users and
lower-than-average ARPU from rural penetration. Higher usage on off-peak
buffet package had push up 3Q08 MOU by 17% y-o-y. On quarterly basis, ARPU
excl. IC declined by 5.5% q-o-q as MOU dropped 1.5% due to the slow usage from
seasonality and the flood in several lower-north provinces.
Postpaid net additions were 149k improved from 16k in the previous quarter due
to stronger push after the clean-up of the low-quality subscribers. Postpaid
ARPU excl. IC increased 1.6% y-o-y to Bt709 as MOU increased 8.1%. However, on
quarterly comparison, ARPU excl. IC declined 4.4% q-o-q as MOU dropped 3.9%
q-o-q from seasonality impact.
FINANCIAL RESULTS
* 9M08 service revenue ex-IC grew 8.6% y-o-y, backed by 8.3% growth in 3Q08,
from prepaid, non-voice, and IDD growth
* Impact from seasonality and the flooding reflected in 1.9% q-o-q drop in
service revenues
* Reported net profit of Bt4.53bn, grew 29% y-o-y
Service revenue
(Bt million)
Service revenue 3Q08 3Q07 2Q08 y-o-y q-o-q
excluding IC
Voice revenue 15,832 76.6% 15,380 80.6% 16,288 77.3% 2.9% -2.8%
Postpaid (voice) 3,728 18.0% 4,111 21.5% 3,845 18.3% -9.3% -3.0%
Prepaid (voice) 12,104 58.6% 11,269 59.1% 12,443 59.1% 7.4% -2.7%
Non-voice revenue 2,784 13.5% 2,109 11.1% 2,665 12.7% 32.0% 4.5%
International roaming 919 4.4% 837 4.4% 952 4.5% 9.9% -3.4%
Others
(IDD, other fees) 1,130 5.5% 753 3.9% 1,155 5.5% 50.0% -2.2%
20,665 100.0% 19,079 100.0% 21,060 100.0% 8.3% -1.9%
Service revenues excl. IC for 3Q08 increased 8.3% y-o-y, fuelled by strong
growth from prepaid voice revenues, non-voice, and international calls.
Comparing q-o-q, service revenues slightly declined by 1.9% mainly from soft
seasonality, as well as the impact of the flood in the Northern area. However,
the strong data revenue helped mitigated the seasonality effect.
For 9M08, service revenue excl. IC rose 8.6% y-o-y, to Bt63,151m, from
Bt58,168m, due to strong growth in prepaid voice revenues, non-voice revenues,
international call and international roaming.
Voice revenue in 3Q08 increased 2.9% y-o-y, from 7.4% growth in voice revenue
from prepaid but was dragged by 9.3% drop from postpaid voice revenue.
Postpaid revenues were abnormally high last year due to the aggressive postpaid
subscriber acquisition. On q-o-q basis, voice revenue decreased by 2.8%
reflected softer usage from seasonality, as voice revenue from both postpaid
and prepaid dropped by 3% and 2.7% respectively. During 3Q08, AIS had
increased tariffs on certain groups of existing prepaid subscribers.
Non-voice revenue for 3Q08 continued its strong growth momentum of 32% y-o-y
and 4.5% q-o-q. It contributed 13.5% of service revenue (excl. IC) in 3Q08,
increased from 11.1% in 3Q07. The y-o-y growth was mainly from higher GPRS
consumption, as well as higher GPRS subscribers which grew 50% y-o-y and 12.5%
q-o-q, to 4.5m. Despite seasonality effect, non-voice revenues still grew 4.5%
q-o-q from GPRS and SMS. 9M08 non-voice revenue increased 29.3% y-o-y,
mainly driven by GPRS/EDGE usage.
International roaming & international call in 3Q08 seasonally declined q-o-q
by 3.4% but grew 9.9% y-o-y. IDD revenue surged 50% y-o-y from the full
service launch on AIN international telephone gateway. For 9M08, international
roaming grew 12.9% y-o-y to Bt3,018m from Bt2,674m and IDD revenue rose 49.9%
y-o-y to Bt3,553m, from Bt2,371m.
Interconnection revenue/cost
Interconnection (Bt million) 3Q08 3Q07 2Q08 y-o-y q-o-q
Revenue 3,958 4,357 4,144 -9.2% -4.5%
Cost 3,749 3,842 4,080 -2.4% -8.1%
Net interconnection 209 515 64 -59% 225%
* Recognition of IC in 2007 was fully realized only in 4Q07
Net interconnection (IC) for 3Q08 increased to Bt209m from Bt64m in 2Q08. Both
incoming and outgoing traffic were lower q-o-q as reflected in higher on-net
traffic to 75% from 73% in 2Q08. The outgoing off-net minutes declined due to
tariff increase, while incoming off-net minutes from the IC corresponding
parties (DTAC and True Move) were also lower but at a slower rate, hence net
IC increased q-o-q. For 9M08 net IC was Bt390m.
Sales revenues dropped by 12.7% y-o-y and 7.5% q-o-q due to lower unit sales
of handset, which dropped 8.9% y-o-y and 11.8% q-o-q to 895k in 3Q08. 9M08
sales revenues decreased 13.5%, from Bt10,416m to Bt9,012m.
Cost of service
Cost of service excl. IC 3Q08 3Q07 2Q08 y-o-y q-o-q
(Bt million)
Amortization 4,523 4,288 4,426 5.5% 2.2%
Base station rental & utility 622 580 628 7.3% -1.0%
Maintenance 500 488 427 2.6% 17.1%
Others 954 884 929 7.9% 2.6%
6,599 6,239 6,411 5.8% 2.9%
Cost of service excluding IC cost for 3Q08 was Bt6,599m, up 5.8% y-o-y and
2.9% q-o-q mainly from higher amortization which increased 5.5% y-o-y and
2.2% q-o-q as the amortization period becomes shorter according to the remaining
concession life. Base station rental & utility increased 7.3% y-o-y from cell
sites expansion from 12,400 in 3Q07 to 14,000 in 3Q08. Maintenance may
fluctuate from quarter to quarter which caused the 17% q-o-q increase, however
9M08 maintenance dropped 3% y-o-y. For 9M08, costs of service excluding IC
expense increased 7.3% y-o-y, due mainly to 8.3% rise in amortization.
Cost of sales in 3Q08 decreased 12.4% y-o-y and 4.7% q-o-q, followed 12.7%
y-o-y and 7.5% q-o-q drop in sales revenues. Sales margin, normally varies
from quarter to quarter, were 6% in 3Q08, compared to 8.8% in 2Q08 and 6.3% in
3Q07. 9M08 cost of sales dropped 13.7% y-o-y, at the same pace to 13.5% y-o-y
drop in sales revenue.
Concession fee
(Bt million) 3Q08 3Q07 2Q08 y-o-y q-o-q
Concession fee 4,990 4,627 5,051 7.9% -1.2%
%of service revenue excl.IC 24.1% 24.2% 24.0%
Concession fee was 24.1% of service revenue excluding IC, remained flat from
24% in 2Q08 and 24.2% in 3Q07.
SG&A
(Bt million) 3Q08 3Q07 2Q08
%marketing expense to total revenue (excl. IC) 3.3% 3.3% 2.4%
%bad debt to postpaid revenue 2.2% 7.0% 2.2%
%SG&A to total revenue (excl. IC) 11.6% 13.2% 10.8%
SG&A to total revenues excluding IC was 11.6%, increased from 10.8% in 2Q08
from higher marketing expenses, but declined from 13.2% in 3Q07 due to no
amortization of goodwill, and lower bad debt provision. Marketing spending for
3Q08 was 3.3% of total revenue excluding IC, compared to 2.4% in 2Q08 as there
was a prepaid brand refreshing campaign, "Freedom Enjoy" during the quarter.
Bad debt to postpaid revenue remained flat at 2.2%, but significantly
improved from 7.0% in 3Q07 as a result of the better quality of postpaid
subscribers. For 9M08, SG&A to total revenues ex-IC went down from 13.2% in
3Q07 to 11.6% in 3Q08, due to lower bad debt provision and lower marketing
expenses. For the full year, AIS maintains the marketing budget at 4% of total
revenue hence, marketing expense in 4Q08 should accelerate.
EBITDA margin was 41.7%, dropped from 45.5% in 3Q07 due to the impact of IC
recognition. Excluding IC, EBITDA margin improved y-o-y to 47.9% due to
revenue improvement and low bad debt expense. On quarterly basis, EBITDA
margin excl. IC dropped from 49.2% as a result of lower revenues as well as a
higher marketing expense. For 9M08, EBITDA margin excl. IC was 49%, increased
from 45.2% in 9M07, mainly from solid revenue growth and lower provision for
bad debt.
EBITDA (Bt million) 3Q08 3Q07 2Q08 9M08 9M07
Operating profit 6,725 5,463 7,323 21,709 17,187
Depreciation PPE 763 711 752 2,269 2,216
Amortization of computer software 92 108 94 280 340
Amortization of asset under
concession 3,794 3,510 3,708 11,140 10,020
Amortization of concession right 114 114 113 341 341
Amortization of goodwill 0 292 0 - 875
Impairment loss on goodwill 0 - 0 15 -
EBITDA 11,491 10,199 11,994 35,765 30,986
EBITDA margin 41.7% 45.5% 42.3% 42.3% 45.2%
EBITDA excl. IC 11,301 10,199 11,915 35,380 30,986
EBITDA margin excl. IC 47.9% 45.5% 49.2% 49.0% 45.2%
Interest expense for the period declined 2.6% y-o-y but rose 5.7% q-o-q as a
result of additional debt drawn down during the quarter.
Other income dropped q-o-q to Bt184m, from Bt1,944m in the previous quarter
when there was the settlement between DPC, AIS's subsidiary, and DTAC.
Net profit for 3Q08 was Bt4,533m, rose 29.1% y-o-y but dropped 28.4% q-o-q as
there was the one-time gain from DPC settlement in 2Q08. Stripping out
non-recurring items, 3Q08 normalized net income increased 19.2% y-o-y from
improving revenue and lower bad debt expenses. On q-o-q basis, normalized net
profit declined by 11.4% due to seasonality drop in service revenues as well
as higher network amortization and marketing expense. For 9M08, after
adjusting for goodwill amortization, impairment of goodwill and DPC gain,
normalized net profit was Bt14,788m, increased 22.9% y-o-y from Bt12,034m in
9M07. For comparison, the below table was developed to show the comparable net
profit by quarter.
Comparative net profit
Consolidated Tax 3Q08 3Q07 2Q08 y-o-y q-o-q 9M08 9M07 y-o-y
(Bt million) deductible
Net income 4,533 3,512 6,333 29.1% -28.4% 15,990 11,159 43.3%
Add: Goodwill
amortization No 292 876
Impairment of
goodwill No 15
Deduct: Gain on DPC
after Yes (1,217) (1,217)
tax
Normalized net income 4,533 3,804 5,116 19.2% -11.4% 14,788 12,034 22.9%
Add: Actual net IC Yes 294 1,205
Comparative net income 4,533 4,098 5,116 10.6% -11.4% 14,788 13,239 11.7%
Balance sheet structure
Total asset in 3Q08 was Bt127,227m, decreased from Bt128,942m in 4Q07 despite
14% increase in current assets. This was mainly due to the decreased in
networks under concession, which caused by lower additional capex than the
accelerated depreciation rate as a result of shorten concession lives.
Total asset (Bt million) 3Q08 %of total 4Q07 %of total
asset asset
Current Assets 23,534 18.5% 20,586 16.0%
Property and Equipment 8,018 6.3% 8,561 6.6%
Networks under Concession 74,101 58.2% 78,527 60.9%
Intangible asset 10,148 8.0% 10,593 8.2%
Defer tax asset 10,016 7.9% 10,031 7.8%
Others 1,410 1.1% 644 0.5%
Total Assets 127,227 100.0% 128,942 100.0%
Liquidity further improved from higher outstanding cash as well as lower
concession right payable from the DPC settlement. As such, the current ratio
was 84%, compared to 73% as of year end 2007. The company has high level of
liquidity as more than half of current assets are in cash.
Current asset (Bt million) 3Q08 %of total 4Q07 %of total
asset asset
Cash 13,209 10.4% 8,317 6.5%
ST investment 124 0.1% 123 0.1%
Trade receivable 5,306 4.2% 8,054 6.2%
Inventories 2,206 1.7% 1,236 1.0%
Other current assets 2,688 2.1% 2,718 2.1%
Current Assets 23,534 18.5% 20,586 16.0%
Current liabilities (Bt million) 3Q08 %of total 4Q07 %of total
asset asset
Short-term loan 0 0.0% 3,492 2.7%
Trade accounts payable 4,739 3.7% 4,218 3.3%
Current portion of long-term 6,907 5.4% 1,545 1.2%
borrowings
Accrued concession fee 7,483 5.9% 3,634 2.8%
Concession right payable 0 0.0% 4,739 3.7%
Others 8,926 7.0% 10,528 8.2%
Current Liabilities 28,055 22.1% 28,157 21.8%
Capital structure remained strong from the healthy balance sheet with low
financial leverage. Total liability to equity increased to 74% from 67% in
2Q08 due to the loan drawn down during the quarter. Net debt to equity was 26%
increased from 23% as of 2Q08 due to lower retained earnings after the
dividend payment of Bt3 per share in Sep-08.
(Bt million) 3Q07 4Q07 1Q08 2Q08 3Q08
Total interest-bearing debt 33,600 30,349 26,105 30,104 32,500
Total liabilities 56,173 53,481 51,937 51,593 54,199
Total equity 70,308 75,461 80,743 77,359 73,029
Net debt to equity 37% 29% 14% 23% 26%
Total liabilities to equity 80% 71% 64% 67% 74%
Debentures and Loans as of 3Q08 increased to Bt32,500m, from Bt30,104m as of
2Q08 due mainly to the additional long term borrowing amounted USD91.9m to
finance capex. This loan is under the swap process as AIS maintains fully
currency-hedged policy. Of the total outstanding debt, 9% remained exposed to
floating interest rate, the rest was either fixed rate or engaged into fixed
interest swap contract. Effective interest rate was 5.1% per annum down from
5.3% in the previous quarter as a result of lower effective interest rate from
the additional loans.
(Bt million) Balance Balance Repayment(1)
2Q08 3Q08 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Long term loan(2) 10,680 13,829 134 268 268 9,753 268 268
Debenture 19,357 18,608 1,500 6,627 - 4,000 - 8,000
Financial lease 67 63 23 17 12 8 4 -
Total debt 30,104 32,500 1,657 6,912 280 13,761 272 8,268
(1) includes bond issuing cost; (2) includes swap and forward contract
Cash Flow
Cash flow position remained strong to support capex and debt repayment. For
9M08, the group generated Bt31,251m of cash flow from operation (after working
capital), spent Bt8,859m on network investment while repaid debt, short-term
and long-term, amounted Bt5,024m as well as paid dividend amounted Bt18,653m.
Total raised debt amounted to Bt7,058m, of which Bt4,000m was issued as
debenture in 2Q08 and additional long term debt amounted USD91.9m in this
quarter. The net cash increase was Bt5,078m reserved as cash and short-term B/E.
Source and use of fund: 9M08
Source of Fund Bt million Use of Fund Bt million
Operating CF before change
in working capital 38,343 CAPEX & Fixed assets 8,859
Share capital and share premium 283 Repayment of ST borrowing 3,500
Interest received 250 Repayment of LT borrowing 1,524
Disposal of property and equipment 130 Changes in working capital 7,092
Proceed from L-T borrowing 7,058 Dividend Payment 18,653
Short-term investments &
subsidiary 127
Interest paid 1,230
Cash increase 5,078
Total 46,063 Total 46,063
FY2008 Management outlook & strategy
FY 2008 Guidance
Market subscriber forecast 8-10m net additions for the market
Market share 50% revenue market share
Service revenue 7-8% service revenue growth excluding IC
Marketing expense 4% of total revenue excluding IC
Network amortization 10% rise
EBITDA margin 46-47% of total revenue excluding IC
Capex Bt14bn cash capex (no 3G)
Net IC revenue Bt400-600m
For FY08, AIS expect industry subscriber growth of 15-20% y-o-y or a total net
addition of 8-10 millions. SIM penetration is expected to reach 93-96% while
human penetration will be approximately 65-70% as multi-SIM phenomena remains a
significant part in the industry. Pricing environment will continue to be
stable or have slight improvement given each operator tends to set tariff to
reflect the cost of interconnection as well as to better utilize the network
between peak and off-peak hours.
Due to strong revenue momentum in the past several quarters with 8.6% y-o-y
growth for 9M08, service revenue guidance for 2008 is maintained at 7-8%
despite economic slowdown. Although 9M08 EBITDA margin reached 49%, the
guideline is also remained at 46-47%, as many cost items particularly on
marketing spending is normally higher in 2H08 and particularly in 4Q.
The key growth drivers to the revenue and EBITDA are (1) higher penetration in
upcountry areas (2) continued improving voice revenue from stable pricing
environment (3) non-voice growth which grew 29% for 9M08 and (4) higher
contribution from IDD business. In 2007, the launch of IDD business
contributed additional 1.3% of service revenue, and is expected to grow 40-
50% y-o-y in FY08.
AIS targets its network expansion to reach 14,500 base stations by year end
from 14,000 base at the end of 9M08 with the 2G capex budget of Bt14bn
focusing on (1) continued expansion into rural area to differentiate coverage
gap with competitors (2) transportation route such as new roads, expressway,
Bangkok transit system, (3) new residential areas, business and
industrial areas, and tourist attractions. Amortization in 2008 is expected to
rise at 10% y-o-y as the network asset is amortized over the shorter remaining
period of concession life which expired in 2015.
As a largest-subscriber base operator with premium pricing, the traffic
position is highly likely to be net IC receiver. Meanwhile, as the company's
strategy targets on stabilizing revenue market share, the focus has been on
maximizing revenue from the outgoing minutes rather than the incoming
minutes. Although 9M08 net interconnection revenue reached Bt390m, the net IC
for FY08 is expected at Bt400-600m.
FINANCIAL SUMMARY
Consolidated income statement
Unit: Bt. Million 3Q08 3Q07 2Q08 y-o-y q-o-q
Service revenue
excl. IC 20,665 75.1% 19,079 85.1% 21,060 74.3% 8.3 -1.9
IC revenue 3,958 14.4% n/a 0.0% 4,144 14.6% n/a -4.5
Service revenue 24,623 89.4% 19,079 85.1% 25,204 88.9% 29.1 -2.3
Sales revenue 2,905 10.6% 3,328 14.9% 3,141 11.1% -12.7 -7.5
Total revenue 27,528 100.0% 22,407 100.0% 28,345 100.0% 22.9 -2.9
Cost of service
excl. IC (6,599) -24.0% (6,239) -27.8% (6,411) -22.6% 5.8 2.9
IC cost (3,749) -13.6% 0 0.0% (4,080) -14.4% n/a -8.1
Cost of service (10,348) -37.6% (6,239) -27.8% (10,491) -37.0% 65.9 -1.4
Concession & excise tax (4,990) -18.1% (4,627) -20.6% (5,051) -17.8% 7.8 -1.2
Cost of sales (2,730) -9.9% (3,118) -13.9% (2,865) -10.1% -12.4 -4.7
Total cost (18,068) -65.6% (13,984) -62.4% (18,406) -64.9% 29.2 -1.8
Gross profit 9,461 34.4% 8,423 37.6% 9,939 35.1% 12.3 -4.8
SG&A (2,732) -9.9% (2,959) -13.2% (2,613) -9.2% -7.7 4.6
Directors' remuneration (4) 0.0% (2) 0.0% (3) 0.0% 95.7 15.5
Operating profit 6,725 24.4% 5,463 24.4% 7,323 25.8% 23.1 -8.2
Interest expense (417) -1.5% (428) -1.9% (394) -1.4% -2.6 5.7
Other income 184 0.7% 142 0.6% 1,944 6.9% 29.0 -90.6
Exchange gain/(Loss) (23) -0.1% (12) -0.1% 42 0.1% 105.6 -158.4
EBT 6,469 23.5% 5,165 23.0% 8,915 31.5% 25.2 -27.5
Minority interest 6 0.0% 8 0.0% (25) -0.1% -25.3 -125.0
Corporate tax (1,942) -7.1% (1,661) -7.4% (2,557) -9.0% 16.9 -24.1
Net income 4,533 16.5% 3,512 15.7% 6,333 22.3% 29.1 -28.4
Bt. million 9M08 9M07 y-o-y
Service revenue excl. IC 63,151 74.7% 58,168 84.8% 8.6
IC revenue 12,359 14.6% n/a n/a n/a
Service revenue 75,509 89.3% 58,168 84.8% 29.8
Sales revenue 9,012 10.7% 10,416 15.2% -13.5
Total revenue 84,521 100.0% 68,584 100.0% 23.2
(more)